HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | SEARCH RESULT |
| |||||||||
Collections under which this article
appears: Adult Trauma Trauma Thigh Multiple Body Sites/Systemic Bone Trauma - Fracture Surgical Procedures |
Investigation performed at the Section of Orthopaedic
Traumatology, The R Adams Cowley Shock
Trauma Center, The University of Maryland Medical
System, Baltimore, Maryland
*No benefits in any form have been received or
will be received from a commercial party related directly or indirectly to the
subject of this article. No funds were received in support of this
study.
Department
of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Tennessee, 923 East Third Street, Suite
1203, Chatanooga, Tennessee 37421.
Shock Trauma Orthopaedics, The R Adams Cowley Shock
Trauma Center, 22 South Greene Street, Room T3R64,
Baltimore, Maryland 21201-1595. Please address requests for reprints to C. H.
Turen, c/o Elaine P. Bulson, Editor. E-mail address for Elaine P. Bulson: mailto:ebulson@smail.umaryland.edu
Abstract |
---|
Top Abstract Introduction Materials and Methods Results Discussion References |
---|
Methods: Fifty-four multiply injured patients with a total of fifty-nine fractures of the shaft of the femur treated with external fixation followed by planned conversion to intramedullary nail fixation were evaluated in a retrospective review to gather demographic, injury, management, and fracture-healing data for analysis.
Results: The average Injury Severity Score for the fifty-four patients was 29 (range, 13 to 43); the average Glasgow Coma Scale score was 11 (range, 3 to 15). Most patients (forty-four) had additional orthopaedic injuries (average, three; range, zero to eight), and associated injuries such as severe brain injury, solid-organ rupture, chest trauma, and aortic tears were common. Forty fractures were closed, and nineteen fractures were open. According to the system of Gustilo and Anderson, three of the open fractures were type II, eight were type IIIA, and eight were type IIIC. Intramedullary nailing was delayed secondary to medical instability in forty-six patients and secondary to vascular injury in eight. All fractures of the shaft of the femur were stabilized with a unilateral external fixator within the first twenty-four hours after the injury; the average duration of the procedure was thirty minutes. The duration of external fixation averaged seven days (range, one to forty-nine days) before the fixation with the static interlocked intramedullary nail. Forty-nine of the nailing procedures were antegrade, and ten were retrograde. For fifty-five of the fifty-nine fractures, the external fixation was converted to intramedullary nail fixation in a one-stage procedure. The other four fractures were associated with draining pin sites, and skeletal traction to allow pin-site healing was used for an average of ten days (range, eight to fifteen days) after fixator removal and before intramedullary nailing. Follow-up averaged twelve months (range, six to eighty-seven months). Of the fifty-eight fractures available for follow-up until union, fifty-six (97 percent) healed within six months. There were three major complications: one patient died from a pulmonary embolism before union, one patient had a refractory infected nonunion, and one patient had a nonunion with nail failure, which was successfully treated with retrograde exchange nailing. The infection rate was 1.7 percent. Four other patients required a minor reoperation: two were managed with manipulation under anesthesia because of knee stiffness, and two underwent derotation and relocking of the nail because of rotational malalignment. The rate of unplanned reoperations was 11 percent. The average range of motion of the knee was 107 degrees (range, 60 to 140 degrees).
Conclusions: We concluded that immediate external fixation followed by early closed intramedullary nailing is a safe treatment method for fractures of the shaft of the femur in selected multiply injured patients.
Introduction |
---|
Top Abstract Introduction Materials and Methods Results Discussion References |
---|
External fixation is an expedient and minimally invasive method of long-bone fracture stabilization, but there have been reports of high rates of complications when fractures of the femur have been treated with this method until union1,8,13,18. Although there have been numerous studies on the efficacy of conversion of external fixation to intramedullary nailing for fractures of the tibia, we are aware of only two small series in which such treatment conversion was performed for fractures of the femur6,22. We postulated that treatment of fractures of the shaft of the femur by immediate external fixation and early conversion to intramedullary nailing in selected patients is a safe and effective method. The purpose of this retrospective review was to determine whether planned two-stage treatment is an effective alternative for management of femoral fractures in patients who are poor candidates for immediate intramedullary nailing.
Materials and Methods |
---|
Top Abstract Introduction Materials and Methods Results Discussion References |
---|
The age of the thirty-five male patients and nineteen female patients in the study averaged thirty-three years (range, fifteen to seventy-one years). Thirty left femora and twenty-nine right femora were fractured. Fifty-five fractures were the result of blunt trauma secondary to (in order of frequency) a motor-vehicle accident, a motorcycle accident, a pedestrian-motor-vehicle accident, and a fall. Four fractures were the result of a penetrating gunshot. Forty fractures were closed. Of the nineteen open fractures, three were graded, according to the system of Gustilo and Anderson9,10, as type II; eight, as type IIIA; and eight, as type IIIC. According to the Orthopaedic Trauma Association classification system14, eighteen of the fifty-nine fractures were classified as 32-A; twenty-four, as 32-B; eight, as 32-C; three, as 33-A3; and six, as 33-C2. Two patients had an associated ipsilateral fracture of the neck of the femur that was treated by reduction and screw fixation. The fracture of the shaft of the femur was then treated by external fixation with subsequent intramedullary nailing with a reconstruction nail.
For the patients in the study group, the managing trauma team delayed intramedullary nailing of the fracture of the shaft of the femur because of physiological instability (forty-six patients) or vascular injury (eight patients). Physiological instability was defined as progressive hypoxia, coagulopathy, hemodynamic instability, elevated intracranial pressures (in patients with a head injury), or a risk of disturbing contained solid-organ injuries or aortic disruptions by changes in patient position or by movement during the femoral nailing procedure. The forty-six physiologically unstable patients included fifteen with a head injury and elevated intracranial pressure (average Glasgow Coma Scale score19, 6; range, 3 to 11) and thirty-one with severe visceral injuries (spleen or liver lacerations).
The Injury Severity Score3 of the study group averaged 29 (range, 13 to 43) compared with an average Injury Severity Score of 21 (range, 9 to 75) for the overall patient group (1507 fractures) treated by femoral intramedullary nailing during the same time period. The Glasgow Coma Scale score for the study group averaged 11 (range, 3 to 15). Forty-four of the patients had additional orthopaedic injuries (average, three additional fractures or dislocations, or both; range, zero to eight).
The treatment protocol involved external fixation of the fracture of the shaft of the femur within the first twenty-four hours after the injury. Forty-six fractures were managed by various configurations of a standard unilateral half-pin external fixator, with two or three five-millimeter half-pins inserted into the proximal and distal femoral fragments and connected in a unilateral frame after fracture reduction. Forty-two Hoffmann external fixators (Howmedica, Rutherford, New Jersey) and four AO external fixators (Synthes, Paoli, Pennsylvania) were used. Thirteen distal fractures of the shaft of the femur were managed with a knee-bridging frame (Howmedica or Synthes) with pins inserted into the proximal femoral fragment and the proximal part of the tibia. The external fixation of the nineteen open femoral fractures was followed by irrigation and débridement of the fracture site. All pins were inserted with generous skin incisions to avoid skin-tenting.
Intravenous antibiotics (cefazolin, one gram every eight hours) were administered preoperatively and for twenty-four to forty-eight hours postoperatively. Specimens were not taken from the open fracture wounds for culture. The duration of the external fixation procedures averaged thirty minutes for the patients for whom the time for each procedure could be determined.
The external fixator was removed and intramedullary nailing was performed when the managing trauma surgeons deemed the patient to be stable and able to tolerate surgery. A one-stage conversion procedure was considered appropriate for patients with a relatively short duration of external fixation (usually less than two weeks), no signs of systemic infection (that is, if the patient was afebrile and had normal serum leukocyte counts), and no loosening of the external fixator pins or erythema or purulent drainage at the pin sites. Removal of the external fixator, débridement of soft-tissue pin tracks, and curettage of the bone holes were performed during a separate surgical setup before the intramedullary nailing. A static interlocked nail with reaming was used in all patients. There were forty-nine antegrade intramedullary nailing procedures, with a Russell-Taylor nail (Smith and Nephew Orthopaedics, Memphis, Tennessee) used in forty-two of them and an AO titanium nail (Synthes) used in seven. There were ten retrograde nailing procedures; seven Richards supracondylar nails (Smith and Nephew Orthopaedics) and three AO titanium nails were used for those operations.
All eight patients with associated vascular injuries had provisional external fixation of the fracture of the shaft of the femur before vascular bypass grafting with use of saphenous vein autograft (six patients) or vascular conduits (PTFE [polytetrafluoroethylene] Gore-Tex; Gore Industries, Elkton, Maryland) (two patients). Care was taken to ensure that the fracture was stabilized out to length with external fixation before revascularization. During the conversion procedure for the patients with vascular repair, the patient was placed supine on the fracture table and proximal tibial skeletal traction was applied before removal of the external fixator; this was done to decrease the risk of disrupting the vascular reconstruction.
Postoperative management with regard to weight-bearing and the range of motion of the extremity was individualized according to the fracture configuration and stability, the size of the implant, and associated injuries. Routine pin-site care involved cleaning the sites two or three times daily with a half-strength hydrogen peroxide solution (50 percent hydrogen peroxide and 50 percent normal saline solution) with use of a cotton-tipped applicator. Patients were generally advised to restrict weight-bearing on the fractured femur until early callus was noted on follow-up radiographs. Union was defined as a nontender fracture site in a patient who was able to bear full weight and who was seen to have bridging callus on anteroposterior and lateral radiographs.
Results |
---|
Top Abstract Introduction Materials and Methods Results Discussion References |
---|
Of the fifty-eight fractures available for follow-up until union (one patient died before union), fifty-six (97 percent) healed within six months without complications (Fig. 1-A, Fig. 1-B, Fig. 1-C, Fig. 1-D, Fig. 1-E, and Fig. 1-F). Two patients (two fractures) underwent dynamization of the construct by removal of distal interlocking screws at four months, and the fracture healed uneventfully within six months after that procedure. At the time of final follow-up, the average range of flexion of the knee for the fifty-three living patients (fifty-eight fractures) was 107 degrees (range, 60 to 140 degrees). Fifty-two patients (fifty-seven fractures) had more than 90 degrees of knee flexion.
|
|
|
|
|
|
One late aseptic nonunion with nail breakage was successfully treated with retrograde exchange nailing with reaming. This nonunion occurred in an obese sixty-five-year-old woman who had sustained an open supracondylar femoral fracture bilaterally. The femoral fractures were initially treated with débridement and external fixation, with early conversion at two days to retrograde intramedullary nailing on the right side and plate fixation with bone-grafting on the left. She presented eighteen months later, after minor trauma, with a broken nail, and nonunion was confirmed by tomograms. The nonunion healed within four months after the retrograde exchange nailing procedure.
The third patient who had a major complication was an eighteen-year-old man who had sustained a type-IIIC open femoral fracture and an ipsilateral tibial fracture in a motor-vehicle accident. This patient died, ten days after the conversion to an intramedullary nail (approximately two weeks after the external fixation), from a massive pulmonary embolism despite prophylaxis (5000 units of heparin administered subcutaneously twice daily and the use of intermittent pneumatic-compression stockings) to prevent deep-vein thrombosis.
Four other patients required a minor reoperation. Two patients with a bilateral femoral fracture underwent manipulation under anesthesia for knee stiffness. In one, who had a bilateral open supracondylar femoral fracture with intracondylar extension, this procedure resulted in more than 90 degrees of functional motion of each knee. The second patient had a head injury, a severe pelvic fracture, ipsilateral (right) fractures of the neck and shaft of the femur, and a fracture of the shaft of the left femur. Excision of heterotopic bone from the right hip and knee was planned at the time of writing because manipulation had failed to achieve a functional range of motion. Two other patients, with rotational malalignment, underwent derotation and reinsertion of interlocking screws early after the intramedullary nailing. The rate of unplanned reoperations was 11 percent in this series.
Discussion |
---|
Top Abstract Introduction Materials and Methods Results Discussion References |
---|
In the current series of multiply injured patients, immediate intramedullary femoral nailing was postponed because of progressive hypoxia, elevated intracranial pressure, persistent metabolic acidosis, coagulopathy, and severe solid-organ or aortic injuries. Patients with lower-limb ischemia from a vascular injury associated with a femoral fracture also had the nailing delayed until external fixation and revascularization was completed. After consultation with the trauma surgeons, anesthesiologists, neurosurgeons, and orthopaedists, it was decided that, for these patients, external fixation was the most expedient and atraumatic means of femoral fracture fixation. The philosophy at our center is that skeletal traction is a poor method of femoral fracture stabilization in this patient population and that early external fixation of the shaft of the femur provides substantial benefits to the patient.
Options for surgical stabilization of fractures of the shaft of the femur include plate fixation, intramedullary nailing with or without reaming, and external fixation. Both open plate fixation and intramedullary nailing entail greater blood loss and require increased operative time compared with closed reduction and external fixation of a fracture of the femur. Although retrograde nailing off the fracture table may afford shorter operative times and decreased blood loss compared with antegrade intramedullary nail fixation, two recent prospective randomized studies15,20 comparing retrograde and antegrade nailing for fractures of the shaft of the femur demonstrated that retrograde nailing had no advantage in terms of these parameters. In the current series, the operative time for applying external fixation as provisional stabilization of a fracture of the shaft of the femur averaged only thirty minutes.
Unfortunately, definitive treatment of fractures of the femur with external fixation until union is associated with a high risk of several complications. Nonunion in up to 20 percent of patients, deep pin-track infection in up to 20 percent, and knee stiffness in up to 45 percent have all been reported in contemporary series of fractures of the femur treated with external fixation1,8,13,18. We hypothesized that conversion to interlocking intramedullary nailing before the development of complications related to long-term external fixation would be a good alternative for the management of fractures of the femur in multiply injured patients.
Conversion of external fixation to intramedullary nailing in the tibia has been studied extensively. Two noteworthy early reports condemned this treatment protocol because of infection rates of as high as 44 percent (seven of sixteen); however, in both series the patients had extended periods of external fixation and high rates of pin-track infection before nailing11,12. By limiting the duration of external fixation and the associated prevalence of pin-track infection, Blachut et al.4 and Antich-Adrover et al.2 were able to achieve high union rates with low infection rates (less than 6 percent).
We are aware of only two small series in the literature in which planned conversion of external fixation to intramedullary nailing was carried out for fractures of the femur in multiply injured patients. Broos et al.6 reported on ten fractures in nine patients with an average Injury Severity Score of 35.5. All of the fractures healed without complications after an average of twenty-one days of external fixation. There were no infections. Wu and Shih22 reported on a series of fifteen open fractures of the shaft of the femur that were treated with an average of one month of external fixation before nailing; there were nine immediate and six delayed conversions. Fourteen of the fractures united, and two (one treated with immediate conversion and one, with delayed conversion) were complicated by infection. All other reports of which we are aware have described intramedullary nailing as a late procedure for the treatment of complications of external fixation of fractures of the femur1,13.
Our protocol of delayed nailing usually within two weeks after stabilization by external fixation proved to be a safe and effective approach for the management of fractures of the femur in selected multiply injured patients whose physiological instability precluded primary intramedullary nailing. We view the use of this two-stage protocol in patients with ipsilateral vascular disruption as a way to maximize the time available to the vascular surgeon for prompt revascularization of an ischemic extremity. The rates of fracture union (97 percent) and infection (1.7 percent) are comparable with those in previous studies of intramedullary nailing of the femur in similar patient populations7,21. Although the average knee motion of 107 degrees appears to be less than that in series of primary intramedullary nailing of these fractures7,21, we attribute this difference to several factors, including the large number of associated orthopaedic injuries (forty-four of fifty-four patients had multiple fractures) and the overall severe degree of polytrauma in our patient population.
Because fifty patients (fifty-five fractures) had conversion from external fixation to intramedullary nailing in a one-stage procedure, a "safe interval" in traction between fixator removal and definitive nailing appears unnecessary. The importance of experienced clinical judgment in determining whether a one-stage conversion procedure is appropriate for a particular patient should not be underestimated. Clinical and laboratory data indicating a physiologically stable, noncatabolic patient without signs of systemic sepsis, pin-loosening, or pin-track erythema or purulent drainage is required. It must be stressed that most patients in our series underwent conversion within one week after the injury.
The possibility of infection after union is of some concern, considering the relatively short follow-up of our study population. However, the only infection noted in this series developed before union, and published reports of late infection after union of fractures of the femur and tibia treated with conversion from external fixation to intramedullary nailing are extremely rare2,4,6,11,12,22.
It remains unknown how long external fixation can safely remain in place before there is an increase in the risk of infection after conversion to intramedullary nailing. However, we have shown that external fixation, as an interim management technique before one-stage delayed intramedullary nailing, is associated with a low and acceptable infection rate. This early conversion procedure provides the benefits of immediate femoral stabilization and prevents the complications associated with traction. We concluded that immediate external fixation followed by early closed intramedullary nailing is a safe and effective treatment method for fractures of the shaft of the femur in multiply injured patients who cannot tolerate immediate intramedullary nailing but who may benefit from long-bone fixation.
References |
---|
Top Abstract Introduction Materials and Methods Results Discussion References |
---|
| |||||||||
Collections under which this article
appears: Adult Trauma Trauma Thigh Multiple Body Sites/Systemic Bone Trauma - Fracture Surgical Procedures |
HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | SEARCH RESULT |